Review by: Pamela Price, Red, White, and Grew - September 12, 2014
Although the “Dumbing Down” bit of the title is provocative, the most engaging and exciting part of the book’s name is the “what we can do to fight back” part. Yes, homeschooling is included as an option—but it doesn’t work for everyone. Which is why it’s exciting to see so many ideas on the pages of this book. Delisle deserves kudos for his plans. If you care about gifted kids—your own or others, then read the book to learn more about his suggestions and pass it along to the education change agents in your community.
Review by: Lisa Conrad - September 6, 2014
Dumbing Down America felt like a book I had been waiting for since my first child was identified as gifted! As a parent, I appreciated its tone. Our children are more than the sum of their test scores and achievements . . . Gifted children have a right to an education appropriate to their abilities just as much as any other child. This is a rare occurrence in most American schools where they are either ignored or face the elimination of even meager programs due to a lack of understanding on the part of policy makers. If America wants to reverse the trend, it would do well to put into place the recommendations by Dr. Delisle as outlined in Dumbing Down America.
Review: Davidson Institute for Talent Development - May 1, 2014
Overall, this book is an engaging and powerful read, and a passionate call for change that excites readers to join the cause of supporting America’s gifted children. Dumbing Down America takes a comprehensive look at the state of gifted education, offers solutions that can begin now, and emphasizes the importance of providing America’s brightest minds with the chance to be heard. “For too long, genius has been denied and our nation has been deceived. With knowledge, tenacity, a strong collective voice, and a gifted child's needs at the forefront of your efforts, we can do better. Saving smart kids isn't a choice; it's an obligation” (p. 202).